Silver Stackers logo

Silver Stackers

Discussion forum for those
who love to stack precious metals

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Forum registration is temporarily disabled due to a spam attack.
  • Index
  • » Gold
  • » Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

#1 2016-12-22 09:32:21

leon1998
Member
From: United States
Registered: 2014-11-26
Posts: 683
Trades :   

Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

10-year chart showed that GSR (Gold-to-Silver-Ratio) has peaked; and trending DOWN.

Last few months have seen worrisome price movement:
When GSR drops, Silver held up and Gold crashed;
When GSR bounces, Silver crashed and Gold held up.

In summary, gold and silver took turns to plunge, while GSR stepped down month after month. Can't imagine what if GSR drops to below 40.

Offline

The following user says thank you for this post: long88

#2 2016-12-22 10:47:38

clear
Member
From: WA
Registered: 2012-01-12
Posts: 973
Trades :   60 

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

Leo, go all-in silver now and when GSR hits 40 switch for 1.75oz gold.

Offline

The following user says thank you for this post: swoydaz

#3 2016-12-22 11:02:15

leon1998
Member
From: United States
Registered: 2014-11-26
Posts: 683
Trades :   

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

I would go half-in silver, and use the rest half to short gold.

When GSR hits 40, switch silver to gold AND short silver.

There is money to be made. lol

clear wrote:

Leo, go all-in silver now and when GSR hits 40 switch for 1.75oz gold.

Offline

#4 2016-12-22 23:05:47

swoydaz
Silver Stacker
From: Australia
Registered: 2013-06-26
Posts: 4,187
Trades :   493 

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

i wonder what percentage of Australia Post parcels contain physical silver?

So far they are the only winners I know of from trading silver.

Last edited by swoydaz (2016-12-22 23:07:02)


Despite my number of trades I am not a dealer, retailer nor wholesaler.
Just a punter like the majority of us smile

Offline

The following 2 users say thank you for this post: HoldMeTender, billybob888

#5 2016-12-23 00:02:40

Ipv6Ready
Silver Stacker
From: North Sydney
Registered: 2016-01-08
Posts: 1,901
Trades :   37 

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

swoydaz wrote:

i wonder what percentage of Australia Post parcels contain physical silver?

So far they are the only winners I know of from trading silver.

You think there is a more than ten million physical ounces traded in a year?


Looking for 40 pre1944 shilling details in the link
http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … -worn.html

Online

#6 2016-12-23 18:18:39

clear
Member
From: WA
Registered: 2012-01-12
Posts: 973
Trades :   60 

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

leon1998 wrote:

10-year chart showed that GSR (Gold-to-Silver-Ratio) has peaked; and trending DOWN.

Last few months have seen worrisome price movement:
When GSR drops, Silver held up and Gold crashed;
When GSR bounces, Silver crashed and Gold held up.

In summary, gold and silver took turns to plunge, while GSR stepped down month after month. Can't imagine what if GSR drops to below 40.

Leo, GSR widening a bit when do you think it will come down to 40.

Offline

#7 2016-12-25 17:52:51

FSF
New Member
Registered: 2016-12-25
Posts: 7
Trades :   

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

clear wrote:
leon1998 wrote:

10-year chart showed that GSR (Gold-to-Silver-Ratio) has peaked; and trending DOWN.

Last few months have seen worrisome price movement:
When GSR drops, Silver held up and Gold crashed;
When GSR bounces, Silver crashed and Gold held up.

In summary, gold and silver took turns to plunge, while GSR stepped down month after month. Can't imagine what if GSR drops to below 40.

Leo, GSR widening a bit when do you think it will come down to 40.



Since the early 1980s, the GSR has never even traded below about 45 or so except for the brief period of time that silver went up around $50 USD per ounce in 2011.  I highly doubt it will ever hit 40 without an exponential rise silver.  I do think that both metals will decline materially from here.  As for the GSR, considering the much wider spread in silver vs. gold, it's a wonder that people even bother bringing this strategy up as an investment thesis.  However, if you're trading etfs it might make some sense.  Except for that the short side of any etf trade will be an expensive one (from an interest or options/futures decay perspective).

Also, I wouldn't be all that surprised if gold were to get to a 100 to 1 ratio and stay there if a fundamental long term preference of stackers takes hold as a permanent preference.  Silver is arguable not even a "precious metal" in the eyes of most people.  An ounce is usually good for a decent cheaper lunch and that's about it.  On a longer term basis, probably beyond our lifetimes, I wouldn't be surprised if the GSR came down to 10 or 20 or even 5 to 1 because gold somehow loses any sense of real value in the mind of the public considering it has zero functional purpose.  I say that with the caveat that it is a wonderful metal with a wide array of actual purpose except there isn't anywhere near enough of it to use as a functional anything.

Offline

#8 2016-12-26 06:14:55

Pirocco
Member
From: EUSSR
Registered: 2011-05-24
Posts: 4,805
Trades :   
Website

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

FSF wrote:

Also, I wouldn't be all that surprised if gold were to get to a 100 to 1 ratio and stay there if a fundamental long term preference of stackers takes hold as a permanent preference.  Silver is arguable not even a "precious metal" in the eyes of most people.  An ounce is usually good for a decent cheaper lunch and that's about it.  On a longer term basis, probably beyond our lifetimes, I wouldn't be surprised if the GSR came down to 10 or 20 or even 5 to 1 because gold somehow loses any sense of real value in the mind of the public considering it has zero functional purpose.  I say that with the caveat that it is a wonderful metal with a wide array of actual purpose except there isn't anywhere near enough of it to use as a functional anything.

I wouldn't be surprised if angels cover the sky when heaven felt from it.
Central banks seriously decreased their gold purchases this year, 3quarters data sum only 270 tonnes, while previous years were like double a 25% extrapolated year total.
year / tonnes (multiple values = later updates, for ex 2013 ended 2 years later up 625 instead of 387)
(positive = sold, negative = purchased)
2005 663
2006 365
2007 484
2008 235
2009 34
>>> 5592 tonnes gold sold over the period 1997-2009
2010 -77
2011 -455
2012 -544.1
2013 -386.6(2014Q1) > -409.3(2014Q2) > -625.5 (2015Q1)
2014 -477.2(2014Q4) > -588.0(2015Q1) > -590.5 (2015Q2) > -583.9 (2015Q4)
2015 -588.4 (2015Q4) > -566.3 (2016Q1)
2016Q1-3 -271.11

http://www.gold.org/download/file/5283/ … Tables.xls
In a year to year Q1-3 comparison total bar and coin demand dropped 36% and central bank demand 51%. ETFs started 2016 big time and for a change in recent years, bought instead of sold. Nevertheless, since 2011 they sold half of what they accumulated since they came into existence (2003).
So your "stackers permanent preference" appears to me like angels in the sky ...
And oh well, buying cheaper lunches, that's what I do every day all year hence I opted for silver small change, albeit at a too big price tag.

Considering silvers current hedge, things don't look that different from mid last year so probably again a $14-15 bottom. A (temporary because sold out = sold out and they didn't buy more since years) game changer would be ETF's selling like they gold equivalents did in 2013 or so.


Silver won't save you if you act as clueless and careless as with your bank account.
Get in- not disinformed. Last is easiest, visit www.zerohedge.com & Co and hurry to their bullion shops.
Futures: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … ilver.html #9
Central Banks inflict you less gold and fiat: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … tners.html #19

Offline

#9 2016-12-26 07:03:39

tolly_67
Member
Registered: 2010-05-17
Posts: 1,635
Trades :   

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

GSR assumes a relationship which is not set in stone. Using it as a gauge for future gold price movement is foolhardy.

Offline

#10 2016-12-26 07:28:23

clear
Member
From: WA
Registered: 2012-01-12
Posts: 973
Trades :   60 

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

FSF wrote:
clear wrote:
leon1998 wrote:

10-year chart showed that GSR (Gold-to-Silver-Ratio) has peaked; and trending DOWN.

Last few months have seen worrisome price movement:
When GSR drops, Silver held up and Gold crashed;
When GSR bounces, Silver crashed and Gold held up.

In summary, gold and silver took turns to plunge, while GSR stepped down month after month. Can't imagine what if GSR drops to below 40.

Leo, GSR widening a bit when do you think it will come down to 40.



Since the early 1980s, the GSR has never even traded below about 45 or so except for the brief period of time that silver went up around $50 USD per ounce in 2011.  I highly doubt it will ever hit 40 without an exponential rise silver.  I do think that both metals will decline materially from here.  As for the GSR, considering the much wider spread in silver vs. gold, it's a wonder that people even bother bringing this strategy up as an investment thesis.  However, if you're trading etfs it might make some sense.  Except for that the short side of any etf trade will be an expensive one (from an interest or options/futures decay perspective).

Also, I wouldn't be all that surprised if gold were to get to a 100 to 1 ratio and stay there if a fundamental long term preference of stackers takes hold as a permanent preference.  Silver is arguable not even a "precious metal" in the eyes of most people.  An ounce is usually good for a decent cheaper lunch and that's about it.  On a longer term basis, probably beyond our lifetimes, I wouldn't be surprised if the GSR came down to 10 or 20 or even 5 to 1 because gold somehow loses any sense of real value in the mind of the public considering it has zero functional purpose.  I say that with the caveat that it is a wonderful metal with a wide array of actual purpose except there isn't anywhere near enough of it to use as a functional anything.

  excellent...

Offline

#11 2016-12-26 16:30:29

Pirocco
Member
From: EUSSR
Registered: 2011-05-24
Posts: 4,805
Trades :   
Website

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

tolly_67 wrote:

GSR assumes a relationship which is not set in stone. Using it as a gauge for future gold price movement is foolhardy.

There is some relation between both markets, due to GSR based traders, mainly they use silver on a road to more gold, silvers market tends to contain more suckers, easier to milk, and the freebies chewed out there, then are used to add gold.
So it's indeed not a stone relationship, but still a relationship.
What the price impact is of this part of the silver trading, is an open question.
I think it's substantial, based on the presence of quite some sequences silver price peak > gold price peak in the historical price trends.
Also, governments tend to lure people away from silver to gold (by selectively buying the latter), which also brings in gsr relevance.
That is what they say themselves, they "support" gold.
Of course, only at times when it serves their anti speculation war position. smile


Silver won't save you if you act as clueless and careless as with your bank account.
Get in- not disinformed. Last is easiest, visit www.zerohedge.com & Co and hurry to their bullion shops.
Futures: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … ilver.html #9
Central Banks inflict you less gold and fiat: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … tners.html #19

Offline

The following user says thank you for this post: mmissinglink

#12 2016-12-29 06:19:13

Pirocco
Member
From: EUSSR
Registered: 2011-05-24
Posts: 4,805
Trades :   
Website

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

I don't see much data indicating a lower gold bottom than the $1100 of 1 year ago.
Most of this 1 year upspike was due to ETF's (SPDR, IShares, Sprott, ...) and futures (a 20 years recordhigh total net position of 360K, previous peak 300K in 2009 - the price impact of 1120 tonnes bogus gold demand)
ETF's 340 tonnes during 2016Q1, 237 tonnes Q2, 146 tonnes Q3, totaling 723 tonnes 2016Q1-3
So as it looks like, nothing really much changed in the stackers market.
Of course, if the gold ETF's would start to sell to a further low (at the bottom they still had half of what they bought since they came into existence), golds price would end up at $900 or so.


Silver won't save you if you act as clueless and careless as with your bank account.
Get in- not disinformed. Last is easiest, visit www.zerohedge.com & Co and hurry to their bullion shops.
Futures: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … ilver.html #9
Central Banks inflict you less gold and fiat: http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic- … tners.html #19

Offline

#13 2016-12-29 10:32:52

leon1998
Member
From: United States
Registered: 2014-11-26
Posts: 683
Trades :   

Re: Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

so far, GSR has been bouncing between 68 and 73.

And it seems trending down again, even if silver can retest 17, gold will still be capped below 1160 if GSR goes to 68, too.

I am considering to double down my GLD short once that 1160 is tested.

Offline

  • Index
  • » Gold
  • » Gold is doomed by a declining Gold-to-Silver-Ratio

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB